Thursday 17 August 2017

Sanhedrin 32: Monetary vs. Capital Cases - Pursuing Justice

A very brief outline of today's daf, beginning with a new Mishna:

  • the same laws apply to monetary and capital cases
  • monetary cases - 3 judges
  • capital cases - 23 judges
  • monetary cases have more flexibility in the process of hearing evidence, overturning verdicts, etc.
  • capital cases must be heard within one day
  • monetary and ritual impurity cases may hear first from the greatest Sage
  • capital cases must not hear from the the greatest Sage
  • anyone including a mazer can judge  monetary cases
  • capital cases require a kohen, levite or yisraelite eligible to marry a bat kohen

The Gemara begins its discussion of a number of issues:

  • what are the actual written requirements of monetary cases?
  • how do we know about when loans can be cancelled?
  • what does it mean to truly pursue justice; tzedek tzedek tirdof?
    • we are told of two ships attempting to cross a narrow river 
    • we are told of two camels who meet at the peak of a mountain
    • in both cases, we must consider who was at a disadvantage (further from their destination, laden with a greater burden) to know who should go first
    • if they are equal they must both compromise
  • why do judges begin monetary cases in this way?
Certainly this Gemara will be both broad and long in its discussion of our new Mishna!


No comments:

Post a Comment